Goodfellas Pizzeria of LIC: Delicious Pizza Delights in Long Island City

Best NY pizza pf LIC.Tastiest and also cheapest I will definitely buy another pie again

From a tourist that came all the way from São Paulo, I must say I'm impressed. A very small place with a few workers that deliver an amazing pizza and a very nice service. The tables are on the sidewalk, but that isn't a problem for me. It even adds a bit more charm, to be honest.

Great pizza. This is going to be a regular stop for us. We just went yesterday and was thinking about getting pizza from here again today, it was that good. There’s no indoor seating however they have a seating area on the sidewalk with about half a dozen tables.

Years ago on a business trip to New York I happened to eat at this place, and in the years since I haven’t found a better pizza place in New York. I was on another business trip recently and was nearby so I thought I’d stop by to see if it was still just as good, and yes, yes it was. I highly recommend it. The pepperoni pizza and garlic knots were fantastic, and the value is incredible!

Passed by while waiting around the area and decided to stop by. Wasn’t aware that it was a pickup window only. Picked up a goodfellas slice, margherita and then came back for round 2 to get the chicken bacon ranch. The crust had a great chew and a great under carry, one of the best pie crusts I’ve tasted in my time in NY. The margherita slice was by far the best I’ve had, the cheese used is the perfect consistency for a pie, the good fellas slice was packed with both pepperoni and sausage and had a nice hint of sweetness from the onions. The chicken, bacon, ranch was standard. Not a slice I’d come running back for. Will definitely be back when in NY!

I love the pizza so much that the aroma tempts me to get another couple of slices every time I pass by the block! Both the regular and deep dish style pizzas are delicious. Everything on the menu, from the pizza to the garlic bread and cakes and more, does justice every time. The staff is the best! They make you feel like a family member of theirs. Nothing like great hospitality and great food! Goodfellas keeps my hardcore pizza addiction going!

Very solid option for pizza in LIC! Every slice we got was delicious (though I’m partial to the classic cheese & pepperoni). If you want that thin crust pizza, don’t get the ones with a ton of topping (the dough seems a little thicker to support all the toppings—still VERY tasty though). Keep in mind that this place is take-out only and there isn’t really a place nearby to comfortably sit and eat. If you’re in a grab-and go situation, this is perfect. Service is friendly and decently fast, and I would come back here again for sure.

I stayed in LIC for a few days and didn't have high expectations for this restaurant—it was just the closest one within walking distance. But the pizza turned out to be incredible! I have to say, it's the best pizza I've ever had. It was baked to perfection, and I absolutely loved it. I'll definitely try it again if I return to LIC.